The Key West Mystique

Key West Island News


Key West Island News connects Key West residents and friends of the island, fosters our One Human Family culture and advances understanding of shared goals for our island community

Truman Waterfront frangipani

About that Franklin Graham Sunshine State revival caravan to Key West

By Linda Grist Cunningham, editor and proprietor

Linda Grist Cunningham is editor and proprietor of Key West Island News and KeyWestWatch Media LLC. She and her husband, a park ranger at Fort Zach, live in Key West with their Cat 5s.


Wednesday night was camp revival at the river. Folks from all over would gather in Stumpy Bottom for the preaching, the fellowship, the singing and the sure-fire altar calls. It was hot and sweaty inside that tent, but no one much cared. It was revival night. God was on stage or at least his emissaries were.

A bunch of teenagers and I skulked around the edges peering in the tent doors and under the side flaps. Good Methodists and Presbyterians were we all and we sure didn’t hear that kind of preaching in our dignified sanctuaries. If there were an altar call, it rarely involved the waving of hands or the speaking in tongues.

We were curious kids shooed gently away by the deacons who asked us kindly to come inside or head for home. We went home. Our mothers would snatch us bald were we inside that tent. It simply was not the done thing.

One doesn’t grow up in the Appalachian South of the 1950s, ’60s and ’70s without crossing paths with the fundamentalists for whom emotionally wrenching, interactive worship was what Sundays, Wednesdays and two weeks in the summer was all about. Snakes, too. I’ve watched serpents in terrified, mystified awe.

My classmates shared — sometimes too forthrightly, I thought — their fundamental, evangelical zeal by leaving tracts on my desk to convince me that my mainstream Presbyterian soul was headed straight to hell (these were the only kids allowed to say the word hell aloud) should I not recant. Dancing, makeup, short skirts should go.

I remember the names of every one of those kids. Not because they spent their time proselytizing, today we’d say bullying me, but because they made me think — and they cared deeply about me, the almost stranger I was to them. Their faith was so confident, so unshakeable, so filled with rules they could follow and checklists they could check. Mine felt kinda mushy beside theirs.

Those childhood experiences born from and pushing forward the traditions of Oral Roberts, Jerry Falwell and Billy Graham and countless local pastors taught me three things:

  • If you are a person of faith, you’d best clarify and distill what you believe or you’ll be tossing in the wind;
  • You’ve got to walk the things in which you believe every day even when it’s hard or uncomfortable;
  • And, there’s room for a whole bunch of different styles. We can sing it differently, but the music is pretty much the same.

My personal faith statement is woven from several Bible verses: “Show me my path. Teach me along the way. Direct my anger. Grant me peace. Sustain my hope. Let me laugh. For we will reap if we do not grow weary.”

That’s how I’ve lived my faith for six decades. A fourth-generation Presbyterian of the progressive branch, an elder, Sunday school teacher and today, as the years advance, I’m one of Peace Covenant Presbyterian’s ubiquitous church kitchen ladies who cook and serve the potlucks and casseroles for the shut ins. I take the Beatitudes seriously.

So what to do with Franklin Graham whose brand of exclusionary Christianity and anti-LGBTQ rhetoric are counter to what I believe?  Most of the time I chalk him up to “he’s sure not his legendary dad” and “there’s room for different styles.”

That’s a bit hard to do when Franklin Graham will preach from the Coffee Butler amphitheater at Key West’s Truman Waterfront Park at 7 p.m., Thursday, Jan. 16. His six-stop Sunshine State Tour has drawn thousands already around Florida. Stop one in Jacksonville brought in 7,600; stop two in Plant City another 9,600. (The numbers are from the tour publicists and photos of the events bear that out.) Key West is stop four. The amphitheater seats 3,500, give or take a few.

For the past few weeks, there’s been an undercurrent conversation among many in Key West about whether a protest or a counter-rally or something/anything against Franklin Graham’s island revival is the right thing to do. At a time when civil conversations are all but impossible, can one stand up for what one believes without disrespecting the beliefs of others? Can we celebrate our One Human Family values without ostracizing our neighbors and church mates who will attend, perhaps for reasons we cannot understand? Can we recognize that without Franklin Graham’s Samaritan’s Purse volunteers, our early-days recovery after Hurricane Irma in September 2017 would have been far more challenging. (As one of my skeptical friends says, “Samaritan’s Purse did an exceptional job in the Keys and all for the price of a prayer.”)

Can we accept that Franklin Graham’s First Amendment rights to free speech, assembly and religion are as sacrosanct as ours? Should we do any of that?

I like where our island has found itself today, just hours before the rally. There will be people who come to the amphitheater as believers in Franklin Graham’s message or in memory of his legendary father. There will be those who use the rally as their chance to vent political anger. There will be people who come for their personal convictions and beliefs in equality and social justice.

And, most important perhaps, there will be a hundred or so of us — people of religious faith and no religion — who will stand quietly, peacefully and respectfully near-but-not-at the amphitheater with two sections of the rainbow flag and our One Human Family signs. Larry Blackburn, 2018 Fantasy Fest king, puts it this way in the Facebook event post: We will “celebrate and let the world know that we do not support hate of any kind towards the LGBT community. Franklin Graham will be speaking at the Key West Amphitheater and (likely) preaching his well known hatred towards the LGBT community. We will be gathering to let both Graham and his followers that we do not accept that attitude and show them what One Human Family truly is.”

It took me a while to say I’d show up. But when Larry asked if I thought we should stand down, this is what I finally wrote back: “I think we as Key West would regret not making the public statement that while we support the First Amendment in all its categories, we also are, to our core, believers in One Human Family and our LGBTQ community. Let’s do this. I don’t think we can or should walk away. Franklin Graham’s message does not in any way reflect me. You have my support.”

Will you join me?


If you go:

  • What: Standing up for and celebrating our LGBT rights
  • When: Thursday, Jan. 16. Begin gathering at 5 p.m.; amphitheater event starts at 7 p.m.
  • Where: Gather near the Eco Discovery Center
  • What you should know | From the Facebook event | We will have signs, banners and two 25′ sections of the rainbow flags. You can make and bring your own Pride flags if you wish and you can make your own sign but be advised that if your sign is political or offensive or contain any obscenities you will not be allowed to display it with our group. You can go anywhere else that you like but not with our group. We intend to keep this demonstration PEACEFUL as opposed to stooping to the levels of those that want to see LGBT rights stripped away. Please remember that however you may feel, the group at the amphitheater also has the same first amendment right as we do to be there and say what they wish. Our intent is to PEACEFULLY and respectfully show them that we disagree and let our feelings be known.











Related Posts

Pin It on Pinterest