The Key West Mystique

Key West Island News

 

Key West Island News connects Key West residents and friends of the island, fosters our One Human Family culture and advances understanding of shared goals for our island community

Fort Zach Sargassum

Key West stinks. Record-setting 2021 seaweed turns waters’ edges to sludge

By Linda Grist Cunningham, editor and proprietor

Linda Grist Cunningham is editor and proprietor of Key West Island News and KeyWestWatch Media LLC. She and her husband, a park ranger at Fort Zach, live in Key West with their Cat 5s.

06/22/2021

How about we go down the shore for the afternoon, asks a house guest eager to explore Key West beaches. (Clearly a Jersey girl if she’s using that down the shore thing.) So, we pack the chairs, towels, sunscreen (zinc; reef safe); a couple of adult beverages (illegal); red Solo cups (hides the illegal), snacks and sunglasses and off we go.

I don’t have the heart to warn her: That smell? The one reminiscent of faulty septic systems and dead sea creatures? Those piles of decaying seaweed well up over your ankles? That chocolate pudding sludge at water’s edge? She’s gonna take one sniff and one look and suggest we go to the pool. There will be complaining, of course, about how no one warned her, about how “they” ought to clean it up; about how Key West beaches are a sore disappointment. (Of course they are; we tell visitors that all the time but they don’t believe us. Where are the best beaches in Key West? Pensacola.)

Welcome to the record-breaking 2021 sargassum season in the Florida Keys.

Sargassum season arrives in late May or June and sticks around through hurricane season, which ends Nov. 30. Some years it’s worse than others; 2011 and 2018 were record-setting. This summer is on pace to match or exceed those years. Interestingly, the 2020 sargassum season was pretty light and scientists are trying to figure out why. Maybe Covid-19’s massive, worldwide shutdowns cut back on the befouling of major rivers like the Congo, the Mississippi and the Amazon. The Amazon nutrient plume, for instance, extends 620 miles from shore — and the sargassum loves that hyped-up water.

It’s not as though sargassum just up and appeared one day. It’s been around forever and provides critical cover for baby turtles who live within those blooms until they are ready to face the open ocean. There are accounts of sargassum in the earliest literature; Christopher Columbus noted it and called the area where he saw it in 1492 the Sargasso Sea.

Here’s what you need to know about sargassum season in Key West and the Florida Keys. We’re most certainly not going to get this information from an island marketing campaign.

Sargassum is NOT seagrass. Sargassum is an algae. You can also call sargassum a seaweed. But never seagrass. Seagrass roots in the sand in the water and has long blades. You’ll see fields of seagrass in the shallow waters off our beaches. (If you must walk through them, please do so gently. Best to go around.) Florida has lost about 50 percent of its seagrass since the 1950s due primarily to development along coastal waters, boating impacts and water quality declines.

According to NOAA, “Floating rafts of Sargassum can stretch for miles across the ocean. This floating habitat provides food, refuge, and breeding grounds for an array of animals such as fishes, sea turtles, marine birds, crabs, shrimp, and more. Some animals, like the sargassum fish (in the frogfish family), live their whole lives only in this habitat. Sargassum serves as a primary nursery area for a variety of commercially important fishes such as mahi mahi, jacks, and amberjacks.”

Sargassum stinks but it doesn’t sting. Some folks claim sargassum “stings” them. Nah. Not the sargassum. It’s harmless. But, the microscopic sea creatures (think jellyfish) that live within the floating pads? They tend to get mightily annoyed when you invade their home. That stink is hydrogen sulfide gas, which is mostly just bothersome. However, people with asthma or other respiratory illnesses might want to avoid the worst days because the gas can trigger unwelcome reactions in the eyes, nose, throat and lungs.

The city and county clean their beaches. The state does not. If you rise with the morning sun for your walk along the beach, you’ll often find city and county workers plowing through mounds of sargassum and hauling it away. That means beaches like Smathers and Higgs look and smell halfway decent for part of the day. That’s the stuff on the sand. The stuff in the water? Well, it stays in the water and relentlessly floods back. The state doesn’t even bother. The beach at Fort Zachary Taylor State Park is piled high with sargassum and the floating pads extend far from shore. And it’s going to stay that way until a storm comes in and washes it away.

You can’t get away from it. I see posts all over travel websites asking where folks can find beaches without sargassum. For sure, there’s no escape anywhere in the Caribbean, Florida, Mexico’s gulf-side resorts or Central America. The University of South Florida does a great job tracking the sargassum flow, so if you’re traveling, it’s a good resource.

Thank your nose. Within a couple minutes your nose shuts down its sensors. Stink gone. Breathing resumed. Just don’t breathe too deeply over your coffee. Coffee and coffee beans “clear the nose palette,” so to speak and you’re back to the stink.

5 Comments

  1. I wish this info was easier to find – BEFORE I had booked our once in a lifetime trip to Key West. Traveling at at “peak stench” doesn’t sound enjoyable at All!

    Reply
    • Laura, you should be fine if you’re coming down in the next few weeks or so. We have at least some sargassum year-round and the worst is usually June, July and August. I was out on several Key West beaches this past weekend and things were good, especially at Fort Zach. The city cleans Smathers regularly and the county cleans Higgs so the shore lines are fine. A lot depends on the winds and currents and those have been helpful recently. Summers in Key West (about May to the end of October) are always a challenge for vacations between the hot, humid, rainy weather and, of course, because it’s hurricane season. Still, I think you’ll find your visit enjoyable.

      Reply
      • Linda, I’m thinking about coming the week after Labor Day – Sept 11 – 18. Looks like maybe the smell won’t be an issue then since this comment is from last week? A bit off topic but what about this hurricane possibility off Africa – do you think that is a bad week to come? I’m also not sure about how much is shut down b/c of covid. I know I’ll be going to Key West eventually, I’m just having a really hard time deciding if this is the right time to go. Thanks!

        Reply
        • I really can’t predict that precisely; all depends on the weather. Sargassum is a greater challenge when it is hot and humid and/or if we’ve had storms coming in from the east and south. As far as hurricanes are concerned: hurricane season is June 1-Nov.30 and we have had hurricanes earlier and later. The high time for hurricanes is August, September and October and there’s no way to predict when, where and how strong until a few days to a week before. As for Covid: Pretty much everything is open, although some places do close for September vacations (that happens every year regardless of Covid.) Covid closures change depending on how cases are going, but there is no mandatory closure since Florida’s governor does not allow that. We have a lot of Covid here on the island and it isn’t getting any better. While masks cannot be required in Florida, many places do require them. Wish I had more precise information. September weather is always hot and humid and often stormy with possible hurricanes. It’s the slow season so many businesses take the opportunity to close for a few weeks to a month. Covid makes visiting safely a greater challenge. Bottom line? You can always find ways to enjoy a safe vacation in Key West. PS: Make sure you have trip insurance that covers you if there is a hurricane and a mandatory evacuation. Most places will not refund you if you can’t get here because of a storm and/or have to evacuate.

          Reply
          • Wow, thank you so much for the detailed reply, I really appreciate it!

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related columns from Key West Island News

Key West Fantasy Fest | How long can it hold on?

Key West Fantasy Fest | How long can it hold on?

Since 1979, Key West's Fantasy Fest has been the gorilla of annual events. Created by a small local group as a way to jump start the island's late summer doldrums as hurricane season came to a close and before the snowbirds migrated south, Fantasy Fest brings...

Pin It on Pinterest